metafiction

I saw Atonement yesterday and finally (I think) got wadahell "metafiction" meant. Yup, this coming from someone who did Lolita in Year One. Not the sharpest tool in the box. I just never really got it because okay, literature that's self-referencing, and??? So yesterday when I caught myself feeling vainly satisfied with the love story's embellished ending I thought to myself, "Oh okay, metafiction!" - being made aware that you're reading fiction. Then, the underlying sensation of metafiction: the genuine relief at receiving the ending you instinctively crave but knowing that it is a false lull, since the ending defies reality. Fiction or reality? You can't have both and one is as steeped in tragedy as the other. I am a cop-out. I choose fiction.

The same question occurred to me just now during Wilde - I saw the preview courtesy of the movie site. My first thought was, it seems a person's life doesn't make for good fiction. It doesn't have literary structure and real people very often do silly things that don't make sense, so you don't get the rise and fall of a narrative and characters don't unravel neatly as case studies of human nature. So I thought, well there's my answer again, fiction trumps reality. A biopic needs revisions to fact because embellishments remove that which is cumbersome and unnecessary. At this point I thought of A Beautiful Mind, in which the central love story was left unmolested by realities of infidelity and separation, and I thought of Atonement. The genuine/false sense of satisfaction we all crave for. Makes for better stories; makes for better film.

But I'm thinking about this now and...it doesn't totally make sense. The satisfaction I crave isn't from stories per se but storytelling. The lines between fiction and reality that a film like Atonement draws is different from the lines a biopic would draw. In Atonement Briony uses fiction - literary invention, as recompense to reality, to fill a void, but in a biopic a filmmaker is using fiction - the genre, as a tool to convey reality. So a biopic isn't doomed to be fiction so to speak, meaning it doesn't necessarily require embellishment to fact to be a good story, and any such embellishment doesn't necessarily render the story untruthful. You see it's kind of like history - historians interpret and interpretation is subjective, but we interpret objective fact. (Now I know why we had to watch the Buddy Holly movies in Film and History!)

As for the makers of A Beautiful Mind, they re-imagined (but stopped short of rewriting) history and refracted reality - through exclusion, through interpretation, through screenwriting, through film. They sacrificed some details for what they conceived as better storytelling. On the other hand Wilde plowed through details at the expense of narrative flow. So the problem with biopics is how do you balance fact with fiction; how do you tell a story that's been written for you already? To account for the substandard narrative of a biopic with, "Well that was how it happened," is to simplistically explain a complex question away. How do you tell a story - make a good pic, based on fact? A person's life can make for good fiction. Good fiction depends on the telling, even more than it does the story.

---

Hm, sorry, verbal diarrhea. Apropos of nothing, I just wanted to say I saw b-man's match against Starace just now: excellent. I can see what stace meant when she said clay is the most gratifying surface. Also? I love tennis. I wanted to continue watching but when I saw fungus was next I might have vomited in my mouth.

1 comments:

Anonymous | Sat May 17, 02:44:00 am

Hi long time no write!

I forgot to ask if you liked the Science of Sleep because I just watched it and I really really do.

I need to read/watch Atonement. Why do you think almost-everyone hates the movie? (And I'm glad you don't because I want to like it)