#8
作品8號的感覺有點像作品6號感動沒有打到心坎裡去
好聽卻沒有想一直重聽
沒有想要背歌詞
雖然我真的很喜歡「諾亞方舟」
雖然看了「洗衣幾」的歌詞,想哭
可是
就大概這樣
But you know what I really think. And this is possibly heretical to the five of them because they see themselves as a unit, as a whole -- or maybe it is unspoken -- I think the quality of their albums is directly related to the amount of creative direction ashin asserts. And I'm not talking about composition -- if anything, #7 showed that he isn't necessarily the strongest composer -- I'm talking about conceptualisation. There's a reason he wrote「後。青春期的詩」 as a two-minute song, and there's a reason it's track 11. It's just what he does; it's his role in Mayday. He's the one who doesn't think in the form of singles and tracks, but in albums. But I think he ran out of time with #8.
To be honest, #8 sounds like patchwork. It sounds like a great idea that was poorly executed, random and disparate in certain parts, with glimpses of potentially really good stuff in between. I don't know when 「諾亞方舟」was floated but I have a feeling it didn't surface early enough because if you listen to it on its own, it's actually a really strong record. A record around which you can build an album. Which actually is what they've done, but I think the idea for the song came too late; probably by then most of the other songs had already been written and it was too late to throw things out even though some didn't level up creatively, so I suspect he did the only thing he could -- stitch them together with lyrics. Which can only go so far.
Oh well I guess it is not a terrible album. #6 -- now that was a massive trainwreck; #8 is just...in need of some curation. Looking at the tracks, I would have kept 1, 3, 7, 11, 12 (and the hidden track, and some form of 5) and started over with the rest, but I don't think that could have been done, logistically and otherwise. Which makes me sad because technically, what could be more important than the music, but I suppose that's not so much "technically" as "ideally", and realistically speaking, in the larger scheme of things, I guess...yes.
0 comments:
Post a Comment