Gay Rights, Human Rights

I've always wanted to write about this; I guess now is as good a time as any.

Five years ago I read an article in TIME written by Andrew Sullivan. Sullivan was born in England but he currently resides in the US. He is a political commentator who focuses primarily on American politics and he identifies his political views as conservative. Sullivan is also a homosexual. The opinion piece he wrote for TIME was titled 'Why The M Word Matters to Me'. In it Sullivan talked about his childhood, growing up struggling with his sexuality, and basically argued that gay marriage should be and indeed is a civil necessity. There is no 'gay marriage'. Gay marriage is marriage, period. It is a right that should be extended to all and as much as various religions frown upon it, that is a religious issue. Not a civil or legal one. 

It was true then, and it is true now - the article remains one of the most influential things I've ever read. Not only did it shape my views about gay rights, it nudged me towards pursuing journalism. Now I no longer want to be a journalist but for many many years that was something I aspired to do. And I attribute that primarily to Sullivan; that is how big an impact the article had on me. 

I believe in Sullivan when he says homosexuality is something you're born with. Some might partake in same-sex relationships for experimental reasons but that does not discount the substantially larger number of people who are actually born as homosexuals and cannot help being so. These are human beings. This is human rights. It is easy to put a name to it and say 'gay rights' but that sometimes implies that these rights are special and I take offense at the implication. These are not gay rights that have to be created out of nowhere to protect gays. These are human rights that need to be extended to gays - that, to me, is the definition of gay rights.

The idea that legalising homosexuality in Singapore and legalising same-sex marriage in the US might lead to a promotion of homosexual lifestyle is beside the point. The argument that legalising same-sex marriage might lead to a plunge in birth rate is beside the point. The argument that same-sex marriage will threaten the social fabric is beside the point. Gay rights is about the homosexuals, that's all, full stop. Whether or not it has knock-on effects on society shouldn't impinge on the fundamental rights of homosexuals to exist as equals to other human beings. It simply cannot be a case of "Sorry! We have to sacrifice rights for these human beings because it's for the larger good!" Because that's basically saying homosexuals aren't human beings unless it is socially convenient. 

As for various religions condemning homosexuality - far be it for me to say they cannot do so. But this has nothing to do with law. Religions such as Christianity and Islam identify homosexuality as a religious and moral sin, and oppose its decriminalisation. But there is a strict line separating religious sin and legal crime -- by criminalising homosexuality we are saying this is illegal. But the religious position is this is a moral sin, defined by religious scripture. It should have nothing to do with what the law prescribes; criminalising homosexuality based on religious belief is as good as saying blasphemy is criminal, as good as the Catholic Church saying divorce is criminal, as good as Buddhist monks saying vegetarianism must be mandatory. It is as good as saying homosexuals aren't human beings unless it is religiously convenient.

I don't believe in a lot of things, I don't have a whole lot of strict entrenched principles on many things, but I believe in this. I believe in gay rights, viscerally. And as much as this will not do me any favours, I dare say the argument that "homosexuality is wrong because religious scripture says so" has to be permanently shelved. Remember slavery? The world changed its mind about that and went with emancipation. This is the next step. I believe gay rights is incontrovertible and something the world at large has to change its mind about. On this I am adamant.

15 comments:

lammie | Sun Apr 26, 01:28:00 pm

As for various religions condemning homosexuality - far be it for me to say they cannot do so. But this has nothing to do with law. Religions such as Christianity and Islam identify homosexuality as a religious and moral sin, and oppose its decriminalisation. But there is a strict line separating religious sin and legal crime -- by criminalising homosexuality we are saying this is illegal. But the religious position is this is a moral sin, defined by religious scripture. It should have nothing to do with what the law prescribes.
That's an interesting point, and let me first say that I don't necessarily agree with the retention of S377A, but I just thought I'd put this out there -- why shouldn't the law be consonant with religious beliefs? A lot of the laws we have nowadays are guided by moral precepts/rooted in moralistic foundations. Which is why it's a crime to commit murder, commit incest, steal.....etc etc. The law also has a pedagogical function -- laws aren't always punitive and they don't always contain enforceable rights -- sometimes they're just to exhort certain moral values. (Of course, whether or not it is universally agreed that certain things *are* moral values in the first place is, of course, another matter entirely). So it makes sense that homosexuality was criminalized in our criminal code (I say was because we inherited alot of our laws from Englishmen who drafted them in the 1800s) -- homosexuality was perceived to be something so morally pernicious that it had to be criminalized.

All that said, I think that, like you, I don't agree that homosexuality should be a crime -- it was probably considered highly appropriate to criminalize homosexuality in 19th century England but obviously times, and society, have changed and our laws need to reflect that...

Just my 2 cents on this issue =) You should keep up posts like this because they are thought-provoking, and I enjoy reading & commenting on them! =)

lammie | Sun Apr 26, 01:32:00 pm

Gay rights is about the homosexuals, that's all, full stop. Whether or not it has knock-on effects on society shouldn't impinge on the fundamental rights of homosexuals to exist as equals to other human beings. It simply cannot be a case of "Sorry! We have to sacrifice rights for these human beings because it's for the larger good!" Because that's basically saying homosexuals aren't human beings unless it is socially convenient. I agree with this. As I've told you before, I haven't thought much about the issue of gay *rights* so I can't say what my position on this is yet.... but certainly, those who argue things like same-sex marriages shouldn't be legalized because doing so will be harmful for society, etc etc, cannot say that they truly believe in the idea of gay RIGHTS.

mooteh | Sun Apr 26, 02:16:00 pm

You know I did think about that first point. Things like murder, rape, theft, et cetera, seem to be founded on religious precepts indeed. And I agree that it makes sense homosexuality is criminalised because of this long tradition of drawing from religious beliefs...

But I think that mentality has to change. Indeed I think that practice was stopped with the secularisation of government. Why shouldn't law be consonant with religious beliefs? Because law is secular and religion should be kept out of it. That might not have been true in the past but having committed to having a secular state, that separation has to be clear and distinct.

With things like murder, rape, theft - they are guided by religious precepts no doubt, but I think the difference here is those are also recognised by the secular as morally pernicious and not cool. Homosexuality on the other hand, that's up in the air. To me, it's not so much a moral sin per se, as a moral sin as recognised by certain religions. Its condemnation by religious scripture is therefore not shared by those not bound by those religions. So when that condemnation seeps into law, I'm thinking, why am I bound by your religious laws when I am not of your religion? It doesn't make sense. I didn't make the examples clear here but I gave a few others in my FB note -- criminalising homosexuality is like the Catholic Church saying divorce is criminal. They may not allow it and may see that as a religious sin but the line has to be drawn there, the Church's laws cannot and do not equate to secular laws. That is founded on a simple principle - as my friend put it in a comment on my FB note - their Lord is not my Lord.

That is not to say there aren't non-religious people who don't see homosexuality as moral sin per se. To those people I will argue, that's beside the point, whether you see it as moral or not this is about human rights. So the argument is really two fold and distinct though related.

Anyway lammie you said

laws aren't always punitive and they don't always contain enforceable rights That's interesting; got example?

lammie | Sun Apr 26, 03:42:00 pm

1) Oh yes, I agree with what you said above that the law should not assert religious beliefs that aren't also universal (e.g. murder vs vegetarianism). That makes perfect sense so I agree, and I certainly wasn't implying that our laws should do so (I mentioned that in the first post but didn't mean that it represented what I believe). I agree also that certain things like murder, incest, etc are criminalized not so much because they're specific to certain religions but because they're universally recognised as wrong.

2) However, the above point is probably redundant since we both agree that governments generally don't do that (transposing a religious precept into the law) anymore (e.g. England removed their version of S377A a long time ago, etc etc) (unless we are talking about nations that do *not* profess to be secular e.g. many Muslim countries, or states).

And I think it's clear that the reason Singapore has retained S377A is not to reflect a particular religion's beliefs (though that was the case when it was drafted) -- but because of..well, policy reasons relating to the "ideal" of a family, etc etc.

(Btw all of this is in response just to this part of your post:

But this has nothing to do with law... It should have nothing to do with what the law prescribes)

lammie | Sun Apr 26, 03:48:00 pm

Anyway lammie you said

laws aren't always punitive and they don't always contain enforceable rights

That's interesting; got example?
Lol, yes -- like in Family Law (in Singapore, at least). Quite a number of provisions in the Women's Charter (the main statute where family law is concerned) espouse a lot of moral values... (e.g. a provision that says that husband and wife must cooperate with each other as equals to care for their kids, etc) -- but even if you breach such a provision, there are no criminal sanctions, and neither can you try to get a legal remedy even if your spouse has failed to fulfill his spousal roles and care for the family. That provision I mentioned is purely just .... that. No enforceable rights, no punishments, etc -- so, clearly it is trying to put forth a "moral" view of how partners in a marriage should ideally behave =)

mooteh | Sun Apr 26, 04:54:00 pm

And I think it's clear that the reason Singapore has retained S377A is not to reflect a particular religion's beliefs (though that was the case when it was drafted) -- but because of..well, policy reasons relating to the "ideal" of a family, etc etc.Personally I think the religious lobby is stronger than is immediately apparent. And the government is influenced by it because it's a big ass group to piss off, religious anything is taboo and because the various institutions of religion (churches for example) are rich, highly organised and have very broad reach. So while the official line is, homosexuality has not been decriminalised and Act 377A hasn't been repealed because of how it might destabilise the social fabric, a lot of that is derived from an opinion deeply entrenched in religious belief. Not that there's anything wrong with grounding individual opinions in religion but when the lines are blurred, consciously or unconsciously, I'm saying that's dangerous.

So what I'm saying is, I cannot readily look at the failure to repeal 377A and agree that the undisputed reason and motivation behind that has to do with social concerns. Because social concerns are not easily divorced from individual opinion, which are sometimes grounded in religious belief. But that's not bad in itself because these individuals essentially make up society so that's not my point. My point is this is really really complicated. The only way to resolve this and make sure our laws and our civil society are secular, which is the only way individual freedoms can be protected, for me, is to completely reject the social argument. First, because of the possibility that it might be influenced by subjective religious beliefs (which is not a bad thing, it just is, and therefore has to be circumvented); and second because it is beside the point.

I guess I am becoming more and more disillusioned and feel dubious about certain groups of conservative Christians because of this Aware saga. It feels like the (conservative) Christian lobby, perceiving previous political decisions of retaining the criminalisation of homosexuality as success on their part in swaying political opinion, is now trying to do something similar to the public sphere and civil society. I refer specifically to Aware and the various Christian authorities who have spoken up (http://wayangparty.com/?p=8196).

Anyway lams, I don't know I'm getting sooo confused about this whole thing and my opinion about Christians. My whole life I've had a good number of Christian friends but all of them have been reasonable and I can discuss the need to separate faith and politics and all of you will get it, won't get into a tizzy and see that as me trying to attack your faith. And I thought the Thios of the world were essentially few and far between but there have been enough people with whom I am acquainted who have come out after this saga to essentially say, why is everyone attacking the Thios, what they have done is right, they should enjoy the civil liberty to do what they have done, and everyone who has jumped on them are basically suppressing and attacking Christians, as they love to do. That got me really riled up yesterday, that was why I decided to write this.

Now. Not only do I think these people have completely missed the point (that is, I at least do not approve of the Thios because I think they are hijacking what is supposed to be a neutral, secular space to use as a forum for furthering subjective and deeply religious beliefs), I am incredulous at how quick they have jumped to accuse non-Christians of perpetrating religious intolerance. I take deep and personal offense because - what?! It is so easy for a religious group to retreat and say look how we're being victimised as a religion (this acquaintance quoted from the Bible and likened the new Exco of Aware to sheep being sent out into a pack of wolves) and it's so unfair. I mean, I would think when non-Christians in general and in this case non-Christians who have spoken out against the new Exco of Aware are being labelled as wolves, at least according to this person, aren't we being victimised as well?

But that's going into religious conflict already. I guess it is none of my business whether or not some people think I am a sinner and a wolf. However there is a need to make sure that opinion remains private and does not seep into the public sphere and ignite religious conflict, and the only way to do that is to make sure the public sphere is secular. What goes on in churches, in private prayers, among people of similar faith, should be kept in the private sphere. When that spills over, this happens.

lammie | Sun Apr 26, 07:42:00 pm

but there have been enough people with whom I am acquainted who have come out after this saga to essentially say, why is everyone attacking the Thios, what they have done is right, they should enjoy the civil liberty to do what they have done, and everyone who has jumped on them are basically suppressing and attacking Christians, as they love to do.Wah really ah!!!!!

Anyways, I'm sure you don't think otherwise, but indeed, my comments to your post are really just that -- comments (which are thought-provking, I hope, lol) -- I am not attacking your stance and neither do I think you are attacking my religion or anything (lol)

And I certainly appreciate your well-thought out responses!

lam | Sun Apr 26, 07:52:00 pm

oh yah and btw I also hope you don't think I'm intentionally being argumentative just for the sake of it or wat (lol..); I just think that this is a super interesting issue and you raise a lot of points I never thought about before, which thus inspires me to comment.. =)

mooteh | Sun Apr 26, 08:01:00 pm

haha worry not, I liked reading your take on the legal parts. Actually it's always good to hear as many perspectives on any given issue. It IS an interesting discussion isn't it? Especially about civil society, I think beyond the vitriol and ugliness that inevitably accompanies discussions on religion, I think it must be had. Where lines must be drawn, etc...

One of the hons people, a really devout Catholic commented on my FB note and said he was sincerely saddened by what seemed to be a disintegration of tradition, moving away from roots when things and definitions change. I thought that was heart-felt and he had a very good point. Again, another interesting dimension! In this sense the question, "What has become and is to become of our society?" is another necessary conversation.

lammie | Tue Apr 28, 01:30:00 pm

Ahh I finally have time to get back to this issue =)

Ok:

Personally I think the religious lobby is stronger than is immediately apparent. And the government is influenced by it because it's a big ass group to piss off, religious anything is taboo and because the various institutions of religion (churches for example) are rich, highly organised and have very broad reach.
Hmmm.... I'm not entirely sure I agree with this... well, I guess I agree that the government is wary of pissing off *any* of the larger religious groups in Singapore -- Christians being one of them -- but I just am not convinced it's the primary impetus driving the government to retain S377A. Ok, lol, I don't have evidence to back this up, and you may very well be right, obviously, but ... I still think S377A is kept for 2 main reasons:

(1) Social policy reasons
(2) The government is still conservative AND doesn't want to piss off most of Singaporean society, which it (rightly or not) considers is conservative as well (in regards to things like homosexuality).

I think it's more afraid of backlash from the conservative part of our society -- which I think the government believes forms the majority in Singapore -- than of just pissing off the Christians. I think the former is a larger group.

And of course, the government itself is very much conservative. And perhaps they think that their conservative values are, likewise, shared by a huge portion of the country (but of course they might be wrong. Or right. Who knows). But it really does seem that the government has a mindset that's like "we can't do all the "crazy" liberal things the West has done. We need to REMEMBER OUR CONFUCIAN VALUES, and STAY TRADITIONAL AND CONSERVATIVE OR SOCIETY WILL FALL APART"

Of course, I think your point is relevant, and is certainly one factor, but I don't think it's the primary one. (or maybe you weren't implying that?)

Ok, that's just what I think on this point. And I know you probably feel otherwise, lol, but we'll just have to agree to disagree =)

lammie | Tue Apr 28, 01:59:00 pm

Because social concerns are not easily divorced from individual opinion, which are sometimes grounded in religious belief.
Ok, I see what you mean now. And I think it's true/possible that social policy concerns are influenced by a particular culture's or religion's norms and values.

The only way to resolve this and make sure our laws and our civil society are secular, which is the only way individual freedoms can be protectedHmm.. so you are saying that laws need to be secular so as to protect individual freedoms. Yes yes, I believe you are right about that. And I am certain our policymakers are aware of that.

But unfortunately that will never happen, because, as valid a point as that is (the need to protect individual freedoms), that's not the government's top priority (not just Singapore). All governments have to take a stance on any issue and craft policies in a way that they deem is the most beneficial for the population, and will best enable society to function, even if it requires impinging on certain rights or freedoms.

I know you will still say "yeah, valid point perhaps, but THAT'S IRRELEVANT TO WHAT I'M GETTING AT" (lol), but .. I'm not disagreeing with what you said about the need to protect individual freedoms, I'm just saying that what you've expressed is always going to just be that -- an aspirational ideal that all societies should aim to achieve, I guess -- but this is probably going to be very difficult to achieve in real life. And actually I'm sure you're aware of these realities, and I guess you're not so much saying "we NEED to do this", but rather, "we SHOULD do this, as a matter of principle" =)

lammie | Tue Apr 28, 02:07:00 pm

Oh btw

What I find interesting is that my church NEVER publicly (as in, whether in the media or in church itself) makes any comment on things like S377A, homosexuality in general, etc etc. Like, you know how some churches have issued statements on their stance on homosexuality or whatever before rite

Well my church never does that. Which is interesting because we are a large church, and therefore you would imagine that we would want to come out and make our stand known or something

But my church doesn't, and somehow I like it that way.. I get the feeling that when it comes to super controversial issues like this my church prefers adopting a "non-interventionist" policy, lol

And I think it's good, because otherwise it could very well end up alienating some church members (and future church members?)..and also because it might send out the wrong message, that we *DON'T* welcome homosexuals (which should never be the case, of course, whether a church openly takes a stand against homosexuality or not -- blame the sin, but not the sinner, right?...)

I guess it's probably also cos my church is quite "contemporary", and definitely non-denominational. Somehow it seems that the more contemporary and non-denominational churches in Singapore just aren't as "traditional" , and so we don't ... do things like that. That's the vibe I get, anyway!

Hhaha ok, random -- just fyi :)

lammie | Tue Apr 28, 02:12:00 pm

Anyway lams, I don't know I'm getting sooo confused about this whole thing and my opinion about Christians.

Hmm .... I was just thinking about this. Could it be that the reason why I am NOT reacting like the Christians you refer to (like Thio, etc etc) -- is because I am not devout enough??? In other words, not a "true" Christian, as it were? Could it be ah??? (haha) As in... perhaps the reason why I'm saying "wah lao these Christians shouldn't behave like that, shouldn't be so against homosexuality etc etc" isn't because I'm objective, rational, etc etc -- but because I'm a WEAK Christian? If I were a STRONGER, more DEVOTED Christian perhaps I would behave like "the Thios of the world"???


......HAHAHAHAHA. That's certainly ................ something to think about, isn't it

=D

mooteh | Tue Apr 28, 02:20:00 pm

ahahaha lammie you very funny anyway I was going to reply AFTER my exams but on the last comment you made - how to define good Christian?? Whether or not you're "devout" is one criterion but I don't know, surely a sense of self-reflection and awareness..um how to say, like thinking for yourself, interpreting the Bible on your own terms, interpreting your own relationship with God on your own terms, being a good Christian encompasses those too right? Anyway how to define devout also...

lam | Tue Apr 28, 02:52:00 pm

like thinking for yourself, interpreting the Bible on your own terms, interpreting your own relationship with God on your own terms, being a good Christian encompasses those too right?

actually i think it's supposed to be the other way round! like, they say that u *shouldn't* interpret the bible/god's words etc in your own way cos that can lead to you fundamentally misconstruing something god says and then doing something that is TOTALLY not what god intended for u to do. (i.e. like the islamic fundamentalists -- to many "conventional" muslims, they feel that the fundamentalists have totally interpreted the koran wrongly and distorted its teachings, etc, hence ending up doing the "wrong" things). which is why christians should go to church, are encouraged to join bible groups, etc, and not to do it on our own, i guess!


like perhaps god in heaven now is "tsk tsking" at my "belief" that homosexuality is ok because I happen to think it's "natural", etc :|


oops