I've always wanted to write about this; I guess now is as good a time as any.
Five years ago I read an article in TIME written by Andrew Sullivan. Sullivan was born in England but he currently resides in the US. He is a political commentator who focuses primarily on American politics and he identifies his political views as conservative. Sullivan is also a homosexual. The opinion piece he wrote for TIME was titled
'Why The M Word Matters to Me'. In it Sullivan talked about his childhood, growing up struggling with his sexuality, and basically argued that gay marriage should be and indeed is a civil necessity. There is no 'gay marriage'. Gay marriage is marriage, period. It is a right that should be extended to all and as much as various religions frown upon it, that is a religious issue. Not a civil or legal one.
It was true then, and it is true now - the article remains one of the most influential things I've ever read. Not only did it shape my views about gay rights, it nudged me towards pursuing journalism. Now I no longer want to be a journalist but for many many years that was something I aspired to do. And I attribute that primarily to Sullivan; that is how big an impact the article had on me.
I believe in Sullivan when he says homosexuality is something you're born with. Some might partake in same-sex relationships for experimental reasons but that does not discount the substantially larger number of people who are actually born as homosexuals and cannot help being so. These are human beings. This is human rights. It is easy to put a name to it and say 'gay rights' but that sometimes implies that these rights are special and I take offense at the implication. These are not gay rights that have to be created out of nowhere to protect gays. These are human rights that need to be extended to gays - that, to me, is the definition of gay rights.
The idea that legalising homosexuality in Singapore and legalising same-sex marriage in the US might lead to a promotion of homosexual lifestyle is beside the point. The argument that legalising same-sex marriage might lead to a plunge in birth rate is beside the point. The argument that same-sex marriage will threaten the social fabric is beside the point. Gay rights is about the homosexuals, that's all, full stop. Whether or not it has knock-on effects on society shouldn't impinge on the fundamental rights of homosexuals to exist as equals to other human beings. It simply cannot be a case of "Sorry! We have to sacrifice rights for these human beings because it's for the larger good!" Because that's basically saying homosexuals aren't human beings unless it is socially convenient.
As for various religions condemning homosexuality - far be it for me to say they cannot do so. But this has nothing to do with law. Religions such as Christianity and Islam identify homosexuality as a religious and moral sin, and oppose its decriminalisation. But there is a strict line separating religious sin and legal crime -- by criminalising homosexuality we are saying this is illegal. But the religious position is this is a moral sin, defined by religious scripture. It should have nothing to do with what the law prescribes; criminalising homosexuality based on religious belief is as good as saying blasphemy is criminal, as good as the Catholic Church saying divorce is criminal, as good as Buddhist monks saying vegetarianism must be mandatory. It is as good as saying homosexuals aren't human beings unless it is religiously convenient.
I don't believe in a lot of things, I don't have a whole lot of strict entrenched principles on many things, but I believe in this. I believe in gay rights, viscerally. And as much as this will not do me any favours, I dare say the argument that "homosexuality is wrong because religious scripture says so" has to be permanently shelved. Remember slavery? The world changed its mind about that and went with emancipation. This is the next step. I believe gay rights is incontrovertible and something the world at large has to change its mind about. On this I am adamant.